Day5: England 374 & 147; Zimbabwe 285/4dec and 25/1. Match drawn.
At the start of play, the few spectators who troubled to turn out for the last day of a match seemingly condemned to a draw, under overcast skies, were surprised to hear that Zimbabwe had declared at their overnight score.
Sir Humphrey Appleby might have called this a ‘courageous’ decision, had he been acquainted with the unreliability of the Zimbabwe batting. Here they were, still 89 runs behind, with every prospect, were they to be successful in the field, of facing a run chase that could cause them, or certainly their supporters, considerable trauma.
As it was, Nasser Hussain probably missed a trick by his failure to declare at tea, when England were 214 runs ahead and virtually safe from any possibility of defeat. The Zimbabwe batting is notoriously fallible under pressure, and England could have pushed very hard for victory in the final session.
Perhaps this declaration also caught England on the hop, mentally unprepared for a challenging day. Mike Atherton had been off the field for almost three hours on the previous day with a stomach bug and so was not permitted by the laws to open in the second innings, Nick Knight moving up to replace him.
Mark Ramprakash enjoyed a bonus when he off-drove Mluleki Nkala, only for Guy Whittall to misfield and allow the ball to go for four. The next ball, though, he went on a half-hearted drive outside the off stump to edge a catch to keeper Andy Flower, and England were 6 for one.
Nasser Hussain survived a confident lbw appeal from Nkala but, still without scoring, was then given out to the same bowler by umpire Mervyn Kitchen playing no stoke; the replay, however, suggested the ball might have cleared the stumps. England were now 6 for two.
Heath Streak was not at his best, straying in line, but perhaps the English batsmen treated him with too much respect. The score only reached double figures in the 11th over. However, Streak bowled Knight (6) with a superb yorker that uprooted his middle stump, and England were sensationally 12 for three.
When Streak was rested after bowling seven overs, the pressure lifted abruptly. Johnson’s inconsistencies were duly punished, and Hick glanced a leg-side delivery for four. Nkala conceded ten runs off his next over, with Alec Stewart nudging and glancing fours. Hick drove two fours on the off side, but just as England seemed to be regaining the initiative Stewart (15) dabbed at Johnson to be caught at the wicket; England 44 for four.
Andy Flintoff mixed caution with a clear determination to attack, getting off the mark with a four off Johnson through midwicket. Streak returned for Johnson just before lunch, but was too wayward in direction to cause any further damage. At the interval England were 60 for four (Hick 20, Flintoff 9)
Ten minutes after lunch, after a slow start, Flintoff launched a straight six off Pommie Mbangwa. He still did not look convincing, though, or yet a Test player, and hit one agricultural stroke that lobbed a ball towards mid-off, but short of the fielder. He played and missed several times, then waved unwisely as Streak outside the off stump to present Andy Flower with another straight-forward catch; out for 16, and England 73 for five.
This brought in Atherton, batting at number seven for the first time in his entire first-class career. He began slowly, and seemed to make it his policy to wait for the right ball and then lash it for four. He did so with Johnson, hitting successive fours past point and extra cover. He then lost Hick (30), another batsman slashing unnecessarily outside off stump, this time off Johnson, to give Flower another catch and make England 95 for six.
Atherton brought up the 100 with a cover drive for four off Johnson, while Darren Schofield lashed a wide ball from Guy Whittall to the extra-cover boundary. Schofield fell ironically as soon as his fellow leg-spinner came on to bowl, perhaps to the googly, edging a straight-forward catch to Alistair Campbell at slip. England were now 110 for seven.
Atherton then decided to hit Murphy out of the attack, lashing him for three successive fours just before the tea interval – a pull, a cut and a cover drive. At the break England were 125 for seven (Atherton 30, Caddick 2), and a declaration at this stage could have made a fascinating final session.
Murphy decided the better option was to bowl round the wicket to Atherton, which did not discomfort the batsman unduly but did have the effect of drying up the runs. There were ironic cheers from the minute crowd when Caddick finally lashed Mbangwa through the covers for four, then played a classic drive to the boundary in the same over when that bowler was replaced by Whittall. He spoilt it, though, with an indecisive flutter outside off stump to Whittall, presenting Andy Flower with his fourth catch of the innings. He made 12, and England were 139 for eight.
Atherton (34) fell to a superb two-handed diving catch in the gully by Grant Flower, making England 160 for nine. His first-innings century had given England the advantage; now his second innings ensured against defeat. There followed a few stagnant overs as Darren Gough (3) and Ed Giddins did little, until the former slashed at Whittall, who seems to have the ability to pick up cheap wickets against England, and Murphy picked up a fine running catch low to his left at backward point; England all out 147.
Zimbabwe needed a theoretical 237 to win in 13 overs. Grant Flower hit three fours in two overs, two of them the sort of classic strokes one would scarcely expect from a man so out of form, but he fell to a familiar weakness over the last year, failing to get across to a ball from Caddick and being caught by Hick at second slip for 12; Zimbabwe 17 for one.
Whittall (12 not out) scored freely to leg off Gough, but after four serious overs Hussain tossed the ball to Ramprakash, who impersonated six different bowlers – Malcolm Marshall and others – with Whittall so nonplussed that it turned out to be a maiden.
With 5.30 reached, a draw was duly declared, Zimbabwe finishing the series with honour. It must be said, however, that on the last two days England were very far short of the form and drive they had shown at the Lord’s Test.