West Indies v South Africa (5th Test)
Trevor Chesterfield
15-19 January 1999
Day 1: South Africa climb out of trouble
IN CENTURION
South Africa's ability to find the locksmiths to pick the right lock
and effect a jailbreak was highlighted yet again yesterday when
lower-order bravado mixed with top-order common sense to help post a
competitive first innings total.
On what has been one of the better days of this test series sunbathed
Centurion Park played host to moments of drama as well as batting
commitment from South Africa and bowling passion by the West Indies,
with South Africa ending ahead on points on the first day of this
final test at 311 for nine.
Although Mark Boucher's gutsy maiden test century had much to do with
a lower-order rescue act, the credit for South Africa's position of
strength rests with his roommate Jacques Kallis whose batting skills
and temperament overrode whatever the West Indies attempted to do to
upset his concentration levels.
Then again, Courtney Walsh, after missing the Newlands test through
injury, put together the sort of inspiration which had the Windies
bowlers looking meaner, aggressive and more hungry to take wickets.
His 16th five wicket haul saw him move to within four wickets of 400
in a career and his first spell helped him give the West Indies the
edge they needed.
Aiming while for a 5-0 whitewash may be Hansie Cronje's dream, at 123
for six in the 33rd over of the innings and Brian Lara's decision to
send South Africa in to bat reaping handsome reward for the tourists,
a 300 plus first innings total looked to be more than a bridge too
far. But first up stepped the reliable Kallis, joined later by young
Boucher and they relaid the foundation of an innings which had started
crumbling from the first over of the day.
From his advantage point at the other end of the pitch Kallis watched
a procession of partners, although Cronje's innings of 25 arrested the
slide into chaos.
Gary Kirsten, Daryll Cullinan and Jonty Rhodes will not look back on
their efforts with the sort of memories unlikely to raise a smile in
the dressingroom and as much as he was assertive, Cronje's error
proved to be just as costly. But building a match-winning total
requires partnerships and until Boucher joined Kallis when Shaun
Pollock departed there was little likelihood of such a possibility.
At the time Kallis was doing his bit to tape the innings together and
38 out of 123 does not seem the sort of solid raft on which to cling
for survival as the wave of pace bowling and a lively pitch threatened
to swamp the South African effort. Kallis has done it before: all he
needed yesterday was a partner and when Boucher arrived, it was not
all slap-dash. You could see Kallis talking to his roommate and
together patch up the foundations on strokeplay of quality and
sensibility.
Yet again Kallis displayed the sort of class and talent which has
established him as the best batsman in South Africa. There was class
in all his strokes; cover drives, pulls and a hook for six which
underlined his ability to withstand pressure and haul South Africa out
if trouble. There was a neat clip off his toes which saw a Mervyn
Dillon delivery race for one of his seven boundaries.
And went to his half-century with a well-placed pull off that giant of
a warhorse Walsh. There had been only 22 scoring strokes up to that
stage of his innings as he rotated the strike with his younger partner
picking up singles and twos to keep the scoreboard moving.
It says much for Boucher's ability to take over the role of the
innings main supplier of runs, steady himself and allow the bravado to
take root later. So, while Lance Klusener propped up one end Boucher
took on the Windies bowling. Nixon McLean and Dillon did what they
could to unsettle him, but as they discovered it is unwise to bowl
short to the stocky yet talented young East London.
What could be interesting today is how the South African attack handle
the conditions. Lance Klusener was brought into the side at the
expense of David Terbrugge who is carrying an ankle injury picked up
last weekend in a SuperSport Series match for Gauteng against Border
in East London.
As for the West Indies there was the predictable - Reon King earning a
first cap - and the unpredictable with Mervyn Dillon in for Curtly
Ambrose while Floyd Riefer was a late inclusion for Stuart Williams.
Day 2: Lightning strikes for Donald
CENTURION (South Africa) - If Allan Donald had turned his talents to
the culinary variety this West Indies tour chances are he would serve
up grilled Bajan duck, turned nicely, too, to his hungry guests.
Just the sort of meal for South Africans to feast on as the fast
bowler turned chef struck three times in nine balls to rout the
Windies lower order after another feeble batting display against some
shock bowling strategy designed in the dressing room and tactically
perfected in the middle with Donald as the main agent of destruction.
All part of a match plan to sew destruction in the West Indies batting
ranks after lunch on yet another dramatic day's play. And coming as it
did after a heated duel in the sun between Donald and West Indies
captain Brian Lara it added spice to an afternoon's entertainment. As
the words flew around when Lara plastered Donald's bowling around a
sunbathed, sunbaked SuperSport Centurion in before lunch, the West
Indies, or that should read Lara, were back in control of the match.
It was the sort of batting which was as devastating was it was
threatening on a pitch where bounce over the wicket was not as
difficult as when bowling around the wicket. The strokeplay was simply
explosive, the half-century off only 38 balls with 12 fours as Lara
took on the South African fast bowler. A glance at the left hander's
wagon wheel showed how effective he was between point and mid-off as
much as through the mid-wicket and backward of square areas.
Trying to shut down this form of batting is not easy. We saw it in
Durban when Lara and Shivnarine Chanderpaul put together a partnership
of 160 and they plundered the bowling with the sort of gusto which was
as impressive as it was entertaining. There were times today when
Lara's batting seemed to act as a soothing agent after the top-order
had again failed and the good ship Caribbean was listing heavily at
five for two - Darren Ganga going for a duck in his new role as opener
and Philo Wallace departing for four, the first of Donald's five
wickets during his 13 overs.
While Ganga stranded himself in no-man's land and edged Shaun Pollock
in to the waiting hands of Jacques Kallis in the slips, Wallace
dragged the ball into the stumps: committing the error all too often
perpetrated by Gary Kirsten.
Sure there were some harsh words said between Donald and Lara, the
West Indies captain and the umpire, Rudi Koertzen stepped in with
Srinivas Venkataraghavan to curb the flow of vitriol, which Donald
later admitted was ``all part of the game'' and the Warwickshire
teammates (but not in the same season).
``You play the game hard, you play the game aggressive, but that's how
it goes and you have a drink or two after the day's play,'' Donald
admitted with the sort of grin which would have done Frankenstein
proud. ``He did mention to me 's a tough game': we all know that, and
he knew from where I was coming. But he's a good competitor and played
some nice shots before lunch.''
Perhaps Donald did bowl one over too many and get a bit excited the
way Lara was batting and went for five runs an over with seven fours
being hit off his bowling six by Lara. It was magic batting and
Donald, who had every right to be aggrieved, admitted to enjoying the
battle of wits.
Donald said a lot more of the same about the contest between the two
which enlivened the game. After lunch there was a different tactic:
Donald bowling around the wicket with a man back and Lara eliminating
the hook from his repertoire.
After lunch it was Donald, however, who turned up the heat. There was
a particularly hostile over before he followed the words of coach Bob
Woolmer, who had been the Warwickshire coach when Lara played for the
county and Donald was in England with the South African side. Bowling
around the wicked enabled him to get more bounce out of the pitch and
move the ball into the left-hander's ribs.
In the 35th over Donald whipped one in which climbed steeply and
instead of Lara taking evasive action and ducking out of the road he
spooned a catch to Kallis at backward square. All part of the tactics.
From that point, at 102 for three the innings disinter grated through
a succession of poor batting and quality bowling. Donald, after spells
from Lance Klusener and Jacques Kallis, ripped through the bottom
order as the Calypso Collapso theme, so often the discordant note of
this first Test tour, beat their regular tune of inconsistency. And
Donald's second five-wicket haul of this series entrench his position
as the world No1 as well as take his 17th five-wicket haul despite a
slight hamstring niggle.
And as the oculists batting plunged from a position of confidence at
102 for two after lunch to 144, the 5-0 whitewash loomed ominously and
the Trinidad section of the crowd cried in anguish as they looked on
at a distasteful display of batting technique, flawed and totally
lacking in confidence.
With a handy lead of 169, South Africa then plundered a further 100
runs for the loss of Herschelle Gibbs' wicket at the close to stretch
their overall lead to 269. At least we saw Gibbs finally put together
his first half-century of the series in the last innings and then
getting out the following delivery.
There was also a melancholy end to the day's play for the tourists
when Courtney Walsh limped off after three balls of the day remaining
and the knee which has troubled him on occasions seemed to have cried
``enough of this'' and forced him to reluctantly retire for the rest of
the game.
Day 3: Cronje out to crush Windies spirit
Trevor Chesterfield In Centurion
Hansie Cronje has a lot more on his mind than a historic 5-0 whitewash of
the West Indies as the final test moves into the fourth day at Centurion
Park today. The idea emerged that he also has in mind a 7-0 drubbing of the
tourists to set up a an incredible double.
No side has gone on to win a test series 5-0 and then wipe out their
opponents in a limited-overs series. Which is what the carefully
calculating Cronje has in mind: a mouth-watering desert to be wrung out of
the slog circus which starts on Friday.
As Brian Lara's side was beaten to a psychological pulp in searing heat
yesterday and they were set what is an unatainable 569 runs for victory,
Cronje reflected how important it was to establish superiority over any
side and how to win and set up a 5-0 triumph the South African side has to
``still bowl well'' to win the match.
Only two sides, India and Australia have surmounted a 400-plus runs target
to win; India did it against West Indies in Port of Spain in 1975/76,
scoring the runs and losing only four wickets in the process. But if
statistics prove anything, South Africa's second innings of 399 for five,
declared further established South Africa's credentials next to Australia
as the second top test nation in the game today.
A record crowd of 17 500, baking in the sun, watched the once mighty
Windies resemble a side whose record on this tour would even find it hard
for Lara to sell a bat used in this series to a pawn shop for some souviner
hunter. But that is the way the series has gone. It has the all the
markings of Sir Donald Bradman's attitude against England in 1946/47 when
he ground England into the Australian turf and added a solid bit of boot
leather as well.
This West Indies side have managed only once to bat through a day and that
was in the first test at the Wanderers. Since then they have battled to
take a game into the fifth day. They managed it at Newlands through some
remarkable lower-order heroics led by Ridley Jacobs.
While Lara led the attack on Saturday in a remarkable display of batting
which gave the West Indies some hope of showing a competitive streak.
It was a rare duel in the sun between Allan Donald and Lara and added spice
to a boiling afternoon. as the words flew around when Lara plastered
Donald's bowling around a sunbathed colourful test venue, Lara was in
control of the match. It was the sort of batting which was as devastating
was it was threatening on a pitch where bounce over the wicket was not as
difficult as when bowling around the wicket. The strokeplay was simply
explosive, the half-century off only 38 balls with 12 fours as Lara took on
the South African fast bowler.
A glance at the left hander's wagon wheel showed how effective he was
between point and mid-off as much as through the mid-wicket and backward of
square areas.
Lara is still to bat in this second innings, but the grave has already been
dug in a way which displayed the sort of machine-like precision South
Africa have shown this series against a side which has no character and
disappointed leadership on the field.
Milestones tumbled yesterday. Jacques Kallis, now looming as the man of
theseries, scored 485 runs and with 15 wickets, and an innings left in
which to bowl today, has lifted himself into the realms of top
all-rounders, and only the second South African to find his name in a list
of great names which includes only one South African in Aubrey Faulkner
back in 1909/10 in Australia.
Yesterday the Windies bowlers were inclined to bowl too short and paid the
penalty, especially when bowling to Cronje and Jonty Rhodes. And how Rhodes
enjoyed it. His third century and his first in South Africa was a
remarkable piece of footwork and ball placement. But as he said, it was the
sort of innings he enjoys playing. There was a theory that Cronje delayed his declaration to save Donald's
niggling hamstring injury, a factor which might see him rested for the
one-day series. But Cronje rejected the idea although Donald bowled on two
overs yesterday after getting rid of Philo Wallace for four and breach the
Windies order.
Where as Rhodes, Cronje and Gary Kirsten made use of the good batting
conditions, the West Indies have battled to make an impression.
Day 4: Lara sees more trouble ahead
CENTURION (South Africa) - if you are one of those who subscribe to
the Collapso Calypso theory of what went wrong with the West Indies
Test series in South Africa, listening to Brian Lara paint a grim
picture added to the misery of the 5-0 whitewash was part of the
painful exercise Neatly executed at SuperSport Centurion on the fourth
day of the final Test, the Windies crumbled through a mixture of poor
strokeplay and a lack of batting basics which must have made manager
Clive Lloyd and coach Malcolm Marshall wonder about what happened to a
myth called West Indies flair.
Defeat by 351 runs was not so much crushing as it was
humiliation. Little wonder there was some booing from one section of
the crowd of patriotic Caribbean islanders who left the ground as
humiliated and confused as had been the West Indies batting throughout
the series.
What was no doubt bothering them was the tour of Australia starting
later next month. Another tough, non-compromising foe who would like
to repeat what South Africa achieved.
The after lunch twin thrust by Paul Adams, who trapped Lara lbw and
Lance Klusener who found Carl Hooper in front without adding to his
lunch score of 10, said it all: two prized wickets of a side which had
seemingly lost the will to fight until Ridley Jacobs arrived to add
his swashbuckling touch. Tears by Windies supporters from a variety of
islands told of their grief. They had come to South Africa hoping so
much and left with a bruised pride.
Not that the West Indians were alone lacking in batting exercise:
until the fourth Test and the heat if not pressure was off did South
Africa find anyone capable of sticking around long enough to score a
century. The Windies failed to provide one, which is a black mark
against the school of thought which had claimed a dash of spiced rum
mixed with natural batting flair was enough.
If 31-year-old Ridley Jacobs, making his debut, is the best they have
in terms of new talent this summer it says nothing at all for a
first-class system once help up as one of the three pillars of modern
batting technique. Hansie Cronje yesterday became one of six captains
to lead a side in a 5-0 series whitewash. Although South Africa duly
wrapped up the series half an hour of tea yesterday, Cronje was as
cautious about the limited-overs series as he had been about winning
the Test series. He dismissed suggestions the Standard Bank series
would result in stringing together a succession of easy wins.
``All it needs is for one player in any match to pull together a good
performance for your game plan to go awry,'' he said after Jacques
Kallis was named as South Africa's man of the match for the series,
elbowing aside Shaun Pollock.
``Test matches are much harder. They are over five days (normally) and
it requires a lot of team work and playing together as a unit. But one
-day matches are very different. All it needs is for one player to
make an outstanding contribution and you are in trouble,'' he
commented.
Cronje still has a lot of respect for the West Indies side, despite
their abysmal performance this series with only 21 days play squeezed
out of a possible 25; two matches ended in four days, the second test
was over in three and only at the Wanderers (affected by the weather)
and Cape Town went to five.
Cronje felt the timing of his declaration an hour after tea on Sunday
was the right one although Jonty Rhodes had scored a quick century
which perhaps delayed the closure by a few minutes.
``We wanted to leave ourselves with enough time to bowl them out in the
second innings,'' Cronje said. ``I did not want the problem of Old
Trafford again and with Brian (Lara) still to bat, you cannot be sure
of how things are going to turn out,'' he added.
Perhaps it was a cautious approach as Cronje gave his bowlers, minus
Allan Donald yesterday, 180 overs to dismiss the Windies. They needed
only 75.2 overs before they were dismissed for 217 and South Africa
inflicting the second heaviest defeat on the tourists in a test and
the second biggest victory in terms of runs, beaten only by the win
over England at Lords in 1994.
Had it not been for their man of the series, Jacobs, who top-scored
with 78 off 92 balls, the tourists plight would have been even more
embarrassing to watch.
Kallis who picked up Jacobs wicket to take his haul of the series to
17, and along with his 485 runs at 69.29, he was ahead of Pollock who
picked up 29 wickets in the series.
Lara partially admitted after the heavy defeat that his side was
divided and The Management needed to take a hard look at the game in
the West Indies if they were to recover.
``We have been in decline for some time and this the culmination of
that decline,'' he said, admitting the team's top batsmen had not
performed, and this included himself.
For the South African players the 5-0 win means the side earns R750
000 (about US$122,000) with bonuses for wins by four wickets at the
Wanderers, 178 runs at Port Elizabeth, nine wickets at Kingsmead and
by 149 runs at Newlands in Cape Town.
Cronje and his team were awarded the ``man of the match'' award by
adjudicator Denis Lindsay for this Test win.
|