No need to change ICC throwing laws, says Simpson
AFP
24 January 1999
SYDNEY, Jan 24 (AFP) - The rule regarding 'throwing' is clear and
there is no need to alter it, former International Cricket Council
(ICC) match referee Bob Simpson said Sunday.
The controversy over the bowling action of Sri Lankan spinner Muttiah
Muralitharan was reignited in Adelaide Saturday when he was called for
throwing during his second over in a one-day match against England.
The call by Australian umpire Ross Emerson led to a heated discussion
with Sri Lankan captain Arjuna Ranatunga, who took his players from
the field.
They returned after lengthy discussions with officials and match
referee Peter Van Der Merwe.
Emerson no-balled Muralitharan seven times for throwing in Brisbane
three years ago.
Simpson, a former Australian Test captain and team coach, reported
Muralitharan's bowling action two years ago, and Sunday defended the
law.
``The law is absolutely perfect,'' he said.
``We tried to rewrite the law in the 1960s and tried to define what was
a throw. What we have to be careful of is not to make it too
difficult.
``To my mind there is no difference between overstepping the mark,
going wide of the crease or throwing. They're all illegal deliveries.''
It was the first time this summer that Muralitharan had played under
one of the three Australian umpires who called him on the previous
1995-96 tour.
Darrell Hair stood down from Sri Lanka's matches. Tony McQuillan, who
also called Murali three years ago, officiated Saturday with Emerson.
Simpson, now Australia's representative on the ICC panel for suspect
bowling actions, also claims the current review procedure needs
reforming.
He has already recommended the nine-man panel meet regularly, rather
than watch videotapes of a bowler's action and decide its legality by
telephone hook-up.
Along with Muralitharan, Simpson also reported the actions of fellow
Sri Lankan spinner Kumara Dharmasena and Indian Rajesh Chauhan during
the Test series in India in November 1997.
To remain neutral, he was not allowed to sit in judgment on the trio.
Under ICC procedures, the Indian and Sri Lankan boards were asked to
undertake remedial action with their players.
Chauhan did so, submitted the relevant tapes, was given the okay and
returned to the Indian team after being stood down.
Muralitharan also received the all-clear but at no stage did Sri Lanka
stand him down.
Simpson said he had not heard from the panel about Dharmasena, who has
subsequently played.
Last week the ICC took the extraordinary step of issuing a statement
to impress that a bowler is never cleared of suspect bowling actions.
``It is public knowledge that Muttiah Muralitharan's action was
referred to the panel in late 1997,'' the statement read.
``At that time, the panel determined on the video evidence available to
them, that his action was fair.
``Susequently, it has been reported that Muralitharan has been
'cleared' by the ICC. ``The panel can only decide on what has
happened, not what may happen. Boards
and players understand that an umpire can apply Law 24.2, or the above
process can be reactivated, at any time, but without an umpire
prejudging the situation.''
Simpson rebuffed talk that the issue of suspect bowling actions should
be dealt with off the field, taking the heat off the umpires and the
bowlers involved.
``The public humiliation of umpires or players occurs only in media
reports,'' Simpson said.
``The umpire's job is to enforce the laws of the game. It's made more
difficult by the fact that people want to bring emotion into it.
``It's a no-ball and doesn't conform to the rules of the game.''
Copyright 1998-2001 AFP. All rights reserved. All information displayed on
this page (dispatches, photographs, logos), with the exception of CricInfo
logos and trademarks, are protected by intellectual property rights owned
by Agence France Presse. As a consequence you may not copy, reproduce,
modify, transmit, publish, display or in any way commercially exploit any
of the contents of this section without prior written consent of
Agence-France-Presse.
|