Should spy cameras be installed in dressing rooms? Should LBW decisions be referred to the third umpire? Is the ICC Test ranking system fair? The weekly Third Umpire feature throws up both sides of current controversies and asks you to make up your mind. Presenting, as it were, every possible angle to either side of the argument, Third Umpire picks up issues hot from the media griddle and serves them up with liberal helpings of spice. Here are the arguments. Now you be the judge.

Latest:

• Were the Indians right in wearing black arm-bands for Mark Mascarenhas at Kanpur?

• Should England have complained about the umpiring at Kolkata? (23 Jan 2002)
• Is Ajay Ratra's selection justified? (15 Jan 2002)
• Should Alec Stewart and Andrew Caddick be included in the English one-day squad? (03 Jan 2002)
• Should India's leading cricketers be forced to play more domestic cricket? (26 Dec 2001)
• Should Andrew Leipus' contract be renewed? (18 Dec 2001)
• Should India retain John Wright as coach? (12 Dec 2001)
• Did India make a mistake in playing three uncapped medium-pacers at Mohali? (04 Dec 2001)
• Should India include Virender Sehwag in the team for the first Test? (28 Nov 2001)
• Were Alec Stewart, Andrew Caddick and Darren Gough justified in pulling out of the India tour? (13 Nov 2001)